How Bad Is This Bear Market?

“Technically, a bear market is when stocks fall 20% or more from their highs. But there’s a saying that a bear’s true signature is making a fool out of everyone. Based on that, we’re all laughingstocks, because there has been virtually no way to avoid this bear market’s claws.” – Matt Krantz.

An article in today’s edition of USA Today, Bear Market Swipes at More Than Just Stocks by Matt Krantz, spells out just how bad the markets have been this year. Here is a summary:

Following a 445-point slide to 7552 Thursday, the Dow Jones industrial average is down more than 6,600 points from its high. The broad stock market is at it lowest level in 11½ years, with the Standard & Poor’s 500 index off 52% from its high in October 2007 and on pace for its worst year ever, S&P says. Only 13 of its 500 stocks are not down for the year, and more than 100 trade for less than $10 a share.

The pain extends far beyond stocks. Oil has crashed 66% from its record close in early July. Even the so-called safe harbor of gold is down 25.5% from its high in March.

This bear has trashed nearly every investment strategy and asset class. It has humbled some of the most powerful names in the stock market and blown holes through long-held tenets in investing. Market historians strain to think of previous bear markets that have disproved so many investing philosophies at the same time.

“There is nowhere to run and hide,” says Ken Winans of investment management firm Winans International. “You have gotten bludgeoned in every direction.”

The extent of the earth that’s been scorched is breathtaking. Brand-name investors such as Warren Buffett, Carl Icahn and T. Boone Pickens have suffered massive losses. Do-no-wrong mutual fund managers, such as Legg Mason’s Bill Miller, are down big. Hedge funds run by managers once thought to be infallible are having their worst years ever.

Even investors who saw the bear coming have been mauled. Those that rushed into commodities or foreign currencies to sit out problems with the U.S. economy have suffered massive losses.

The pros are struggling

Even investors who’ve sought professional help have been stung. Money poured into mutual funds, hedge funds and private-equity firms run by experts known for out-foxing markets in good times and bad. The bear has proved to be smarter than the fox.

Legg Mason’s Value fund (LMVTX), famous for the longest streak beating the S&P 500 under the leadership of portfolio manager Miller, is struggling. It is down more than 65% this year, the third year in a row that it has lagged behind the market. It now has just a one-star rating, out of a possible five, from Morningstar.

Eddie Lampert, the hedge fund manager for celebrities such as David Geffen and Michael Dell who was routinely compared with Warren Buffett just a few years ago, has seen his investments sour. His personal worth has fallen to $2 billion from $4.5 billion just two years ago, Forbes says. His hedge funds’ biggest investment, Sears Holdings (SHLD), has collapsed 70.5% this year.

Speaking of Buffett, the bear snagged the Oracle of Omaha, too. … Buffett’s personal worth is getting mauled, too. Forbes estimated his net worth at $62 billion in February, but that is based mostly on his large holdings of Berkshire Hathaway stock, which is now down $74,150, or 49%, from its high of $151,650 a share.

Commodities aren’t shelter

Investors who thought they saw the stock crash coming figured they had the answer: commodities. Fears of inflation and economic problems pushed many investors into gold. An ounce of gold soared 53.6% in the year leading up to its peak on March 18 as investors poured in. But investors who piled into gold in March have been dealt a 25.5% loss.

A similar story with oil. The price of crude was soaring earlier this year, and gas prices were a national fixation. At the closing peak of $145.29 a barrel on July 3, crude was up 51% for the year. With predictions of it hitting $200 or more, it seemed like a can’t-lose proposition. Speculators lost and lost big as the price crashed nearly $100 a barrel to about $49 now.

The Reuters/Jefferies CRB index of 19 raw materials dropped more than 4% Thursday, hitting its lowest level since April 29, 2003, according to Bloomberg News.

Global diversification is making things worse

We’ve heard it before. Own both U.S. and foreign stocks, and your portfolio’s ups and downs will be moderated. When domestic stocks zig, foreign stocks are supposed to zag.
But that hasn’t worked either. The iShares MSCI EAFE index fund (EFA), which tracks stocks in developed nations in Europe, Asia and the Far East is down 54.5% this year. That’s worse than U.S. stocks’ decline.

What about emerging markets stocks? Up-and-coming nations such as China, Brazil and India were supposed to be growing fast independent of the U.S. Well, the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets (EEM) index has fared worse, tanking 64%. Every major nation’s stock market is down this year, says S&P’s Capital IQ.

Buy-and-hold investors are getting hurt

Buy-and-hold investors know short-term swings are normal. They hold through tough times, knowing returns come to those who wait. But investors who invested in the S&P 500 10 years ago have seen the value of their stocks decline 35%. Even investors who used dollar-cost averaging and invested $500 a month starting Dec. 31, 1996, and reinvested dividends lost $13,225, or 17%, as of Oct. 31, says Winans.

Bonds are eating away at portfolios

Rather than buffering losses on stocks, corporate bonds are falling apart. The iShares iBoxx Investment Grade Corporate Bond fund (LQD), which invests in bonds with high credit ratings, has a negative return of 14.4% this year. That may not sound that bad, except investors buy bonds because they want very little volatility.

Sam Stovall of S&P says that it’s usually not wise to give up on investing in the depths of a bear market. While it takes five years on average for investors to get their money back after a 40%-plus decline, those who keep investing when stocks are cheaper are made whole faster.

Conclusion

A small point: The article overstates the damage to bond investments. Not all have suffered. In fact, Treasury securities have done quite well this year, as investors have fled to these very safe investments. (As the yield of a bond goes down, the price of the bond goes up.)

But the article is generally correct. Unless the stock market recovers from these low levels, which certainly could still happen, 2008 will go down in history as the worst year ever, as measured by the Standard and Poor’s 500 Index. I believe, though, that this is not the time to get discouraged and abandon your well thought out portfolio. In this instance, doing nothing is preferable to selling everything.

There are some opportunities out there. If you can do it, this is a good time to convert your traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. It might also be a good time to rebalance your portfolio. For more information on these two issues, you should consult your financial advisor.

Going forward, we all must re-examine our actual risk tolerance. When times are good, it’s easy to tell yourself that you can weather the (hopefully) temporary storms of declining stock markets. This year certainly proves that living through a substantial bear market, in real time, is another matter entirely.

Finally, if you are so worried about the stock market that you are having trouble sleeping, consider scaling back your equity allocation. That way you will still maintain some exposure to stocks, rather than making an emotional decision to “sell everything.”

photo credit: lexdennphotography